Is AI deciding your claim? California wants your input by Dec. 12
Updated November 20, 2026. On November 13, 2026, the California Department of Insurance opened a public effort to gather input on how insurers use artificial intelligence. Written comments are due December 12. A virtual workshop is set for December 15, and certain insurers are being surveyed, with responses due December 30. CDI has not proposed new AI rules, and the announcement does not change existing policies, coverage or rates. Here is what the Department is asking, what to request if a claim or nonrenewal seems automated, and how California homeowners and small businesses can weigh in.
What CDI is examining
In its November 13, 2026 press release, CDI said AI and other advanced analytical tools are increasingly used to support claims processing, fraud detection, customer service, underwriting support and operational decision-making. The Department said those tools can improve efficiency, but that without appropriate safeguards they may produce inaccurate outcomes, compromise sensitive personal information, reduce transparency, or amplify unfair bias and discrimination. Commissioner Ricardo Lara said, "Consumers should never be left wondering whether an algorithm, rather than a fair and accountable process, determined their outcome," and that insurers remain accountable for systems they use, including vendor tools: "You can outsource technology, but you cannot outsource responsibility." The effort builds on Bulletin 2022-5 (June 30, 2022), a 2022 public discussion, a 2023 survey of automated decision-making tools, and CDI’s sponsorship of recently chaptered Senate Bill 354, which the Department says strengthens privacy protections for California insurance consumers.
How to comment by December 12
The virtual workshop is on December 15, 2026, at 10 a.m. PST. It ends when everyone who wants to comment has done so, or at 12:00 p.m. PST, whichever is earlier. Consumers, advocates, insurers, researchers and other interested participants are invited, and you do not need technical expertise in AI. CDI asks for experiences, concerns and recommendations on transparency, fairness, privacy, human oversight, accountability and insurer responsibility for third-party vendor technology. Register through the link in CDI’s official invitation, REG-2026-00007, which points to the Zoom webinar registration page.
Email written comments and supporting materials to CDIRegulations@insurance.ca.gov by December 12, 2026, even if you do not attend. Comments will be public, and associated contact information can become a public record under the California Public Records Act. This is not a formal hearing and not a Notice of Proposed Action. CDI is not adopting new AI regulations with this announcement. Any future formal proposal would have its own comment period, and you would need to resubmit comments then if you want them in that official record.
Separately, CDI’s Responsible Use of Artificial Intelligence (RUAI) Survey asks how insurers deploy AI, how they govern those systems, the role of third-party vendors, and operational impacts. Responses are due December 30, 2026. CDI is surveying a representative sample: California-admitted insurers or groups that wrote at least $250 million in 2025 California premiums, plus selected admitted InsurTech companies and selected companies or groups that write through managing general agents. Consumers are not required to complete that survey.
What to ask if a decision seems automated
A computer-assisted review does not change who is responsible for the decision. The insurance company decides the claim or underwriting action. If a denial, nonrenewal, limitation or premium increase is hard to understand, ask the insurer in writing for the specific reason and the documents behind it, and keep copies. An independent broker can help you request those materials and look at replacement coverage, but cannot decide the claim or promise a particular outcome.
For a first-party claim denied in whole or in part, California’s Fair Claims Settlement Practices Regulations require a written decision that lists all bases then known to the insurer and the factual and legal bases for each reason. If the denial relies on a statute, law or policy provision, condition or exclusion, the letter must cite that language and explain how it applies. It must also say you may have the California Department of Insurance review the matter and include that unit’s address and phone number. Those rules are in California Code of Regulations, title 10, section 2695.7. Ask for that letter, the cited policy language and your declarations page.
For an adverse underwriting decision, Insurance Code section 791.10 generally requires the insurer or agent to give the specific reason or reasons, or to tell you that you may receive them in writing if you ask. For a declination, cancellation or nonrenewal of a residential property policy covered by section 675, or an auto policy covered by section 660, the reasons must be provided in writing at the time of the decision. A written request made within 90 business days of the mailed notice generally must be answered within 21 business days with the reasons, supporting information and sources, subject to the statute’s exceptions. Bulletin 2022-5 also states that when insurers use complex algorithms in a declination, limitation, premium increase or other adverse action, the specific reason or reasons must be provided.
If your homeowners policy is being nonrenewed
For the residential policies covered by Insurance Code section 675 (generally, a home used predominantly for residential purposes with no more than four dwelling units, plus related personal property and personal liability coverage that is not primarily commercial), a nonrenewal notice must be delivered or mailed at least 75 days before expiration. It must state the specific reason or reasons and include the insurer’s inquiry number and CDI’s website, phone number and mailing address. If the notice is late, the existing policy stays in force, unchanged, for 75 days from the date the notice is delivered or mailed. Those rules are in Insurance Code section 678 and do not automatically apply to commercial policies.
Start with the written reason, then use our California home insurance non-renewal guide for next steps. If the nonrenewal is tied to a recent wildfire in a Governor-declared emergency area, check whether a one-year moratorium applies; see our wildfire nonrenewal moratorium post. For broader coverage questions, see our California home insurance and small business insurance pages.
How to file a complaint with CDI
If you have already contacted the insurer and remain unsatisfied, you may ask CDI to review the matter. Start on the Department’s Getting Help page, which links to the electronic consumer complaint form. CDI recommends the electronic form. You can also call 1-800-927-4357, or 1-800-482-4833 for TTY, or write the Consumer Services Division, 300 S. Spring Street, Los Angeles, CA 90013. A complaint or workshop comment does not, by itself, change a pending claim or your policy terms.
FAQ: California insurance AI, comments and your rights
Has CDI proposed new AI insurance regulations?
No. The November 13 announcement is a workshop and an industry survey, not a formal rulemaking. Any future proposal would have a separate comment process.
How do I submit comments, and do I have to attend the December 15 workshop?
No. Email comments to CDIRegulations@insurance.ca.gov by December 12, 2026, even if you do not attend. To speak on December 15, register through CDI’s official invitation. The virtual session starts at 10 a.m. PST and ends by noon or when everyone who wants to comment has done so, whichever is earlier.
Who has to complete the RUAI survey?
Consumers do not. CDI is surveying a representative sample of California-admitted insurers or groups that wrote at least $250 million in 2025 California premiums, plus selected admitted InsurTech companies and selected companies or groups that write through managing general agents. Responses are due December 30, 2026.
If my claim was denied, what can I ask the insurer to give me?
Ask for the written denial required under California’s Fair Claims Settlement Practices Regulations, the cited policy language and your declarations page. The carrier decides the claim.
How much notice should I get if my California homeowners policy is nonrenewed?
For residential policies covered by Insurance Code section 675, a nonrenewal notice must be delivered or mailed at least 75 days before expiration and must state the specific reason or reasons. Those rules are in Insurance Code section 678 and do not automatically apply to commercial policies.
What if I think a computer, not a person, made the decision?
Ask the insurer in writing for the specific reason and supporting documents. Bulletin 2022-5 states that when insurers use complex algorithms in a declination, limitation, premium increase or other adverse action, the specific reason or reasons must be provided.
Will sending a workshop comment change my policy or a pending claim?
No. CDI says the announcement does not change existing policies, coverage or rates. A pending claim or nonrenewal is a separate matter with your insurer and, if needed, CDI’s complaint process.
Need a California home or business coverage review? Talk to ESI
ESI Insurance Brokers (Express Service Insurance Agency, Inc. dba ESI Insurance Brokers) is an independent California broker at 2085 Van Ness Avenue, San Francisco, CA 94109. We can help you request claim or nonrenewal documents, review the reason you were given, and look at replacement homeowners or business coverage. We do not decide claims, and a quote is not a coverage determination.
Get a California insurance quote → On the quote page, click the Homeowners Insurance option. For a condo, click Condo Insurance; for a rental property, click Landlord Insurance; for a business building, click Commercial Property Insurance.
Or call (415) 440-5136 · CA LIC# 0G83954 · broker@insurance415.com
Sources
- California Department of Insurance: "Commissioner Lara launches statewide effort to establish consumer safeguards for AI in insurance" (Release 042-2026, Nov. 13, 2026)
- California Department of Insurance: Invitation to Discussion Workshop, REG-2026-00007, "Exploring the Responsible Use of Artificial Intelligence in Insurance" (Nov. 13, 2026)
- California Department of Insurance: Bulletin 2022-5, "Allegations of Racial Bias and Unfair Discrimination in Marketing, Rating, Underwriting, and Claims Practices by the Insurance Industry" (June 30, 2022)
- California Insurance Code section 675 (scope of the residential cancellation and nonrenewal chapter)
- California Insurance Code section 678 (75-day homeowners nonrenewal notice and specific-reason requirement)
- California Insurance Code section 791.10 (specific reasons for adverse underwriting decisions)
- California Code of Regulations, title 10, section 2695.7 (Fair Claims Settlement Practices; written first-party claim denials)
- California Department of Insurance: Getting Help (consumer complaint form, 1-800-927-4357, TTY 1-800-482-4833)
This article is general information, not legal advice or a coverage determination. Your policy terms control, and the insurance company decides claims. Ask your broker how this applies to your situation.
Latest California insurance news
- November 20, 2026After the fire, the mud: what your policy pays when a hillside lets go
After the fire, the mud: what your policy pays when a hillside lets go Updated November 20, 2026. This week's atmospheric river dumped record rain on San Francisco and prompted evacuation warnings...
- November 18, 2026San Francisco streets are flooding today. Why a standard homeowners policy usually won’t pay, and how water backup coverage works
San Francisco streets are flooding today. Why a standard homeowners policy usually won't pay, and how water backup coverage works Updated November 18, 2026. A strong storm is soaking San Francisco today,...
- November 16, 2026California’s wildfire nonrenewal moratorium now covers HOAs, apartments and small business property. Here is how it works
California's wildfire nonrenewal moratorium now covers HOAs, apartments and small business property. Here is how it works Updated November 16, 2026. On November 10, California's Insurance Commissioner ordered a one-year freeze on...


















